A time-calibrated phylogeny of hummingbirds supports stepwise diversification in the Andes

Abstract

Hummingbirds (Trochilidae) represent the second largest avian family, with [~]356 species occupying diverse habitats across the Neotropical and Nearctic regions. Their extensive diversification includes notable adaptations to extreme environments, with nearly one-third of extant taxa belonging to the predominantly high-altitude Coquettes and Brilliants. Although recent work proposed a monophyletic Andean clade uniting these groups, consistent with rapid radiation during Andean orogeny, we find no support for this relationship. Using 2,949 nuclear loci sampled from 47 species spanning all nine major hummingbird clades, we recover a different evolutionary pattern: a stepwise sequence of diversification in which Brilliants are sister to a broader assemblage comprising Coquettes, the genus Patagona, Emeralds, Mountain Gems, and the recently diverged Bees. By assembling complete mitochondrial genomes, we additionally detect significant discordance between nuclear topologies and those derived from the mitogenome and Z chromosome. Analyses of gene-tree heterogeneity show that incomplete lineage sorting is pervasive across the phylogeny, with particularly strong impacts on branches associated with Andean diversification. Divergence-time estimation further indicates that the major Andean radiation--including Brilliants, Coquettes, Emeralds, Bees, and Mountain Gems--originated around [~]14 Ma, with the three younger clades diversifying [~]12 Ma, coinciding with both the mid-Miocene Andean uplift and the mid-Miocene Climate Transition that increased habitat heterogeneity and likely promoted rapid speciation. To support future phylogenomic efforts, we identify a reduced set of highly informative, independent protein-coding loci and present a near-complete species-level phylogeny constrained by our autosomal backbone. Our findings highlight the importance of integrating loci with distinct inheritance modes to detect and interpret phylogenetic incongruence in rapid radiations.