Surprising threats accelerate evidence accumulation for conscious perception

Abstract

Our survival depends on how well we can rapidly detect threats in our environment. To facilitate this, the brain is faster to bring threatening or rewarding visual stimuli into conscious awareness than neutral stimuli. Unexpected events may indicate a potential threat, and yet we tend to respond slower to unexpected than expected stimuli. It is unclear if or how these effects of emotion and expectation interact with ones conscious experience. To investigate this, we presented neutral and fearful faces with different probabilities of occurance in a breaking continuous flash suppression (bCFS) paradigm. Across two experiments, we discovered that fulfilled prior expectations hastened responses to neutral faces but had either no significant effect (Experiment 1) or the opposite effect (Experiment 2) on fearful faces. Drift diffusion modelling revealed that, while prior expectations accelerated stimulus encoding time (associated with the visual cortex), evidence was accumulated at an especially rapid rate for unexpected fearful faces (associated with activity in the right inferior frontal gyrus). Hence, these findings demonstrate a novel interaction between emotion and expectation during bCFS, driven by a unique influence of surprising fearful stimuli that expedites evidence accumulation in a fronto-occipital network.