Seasonal plasticity of symbiotic strategies clarifies coral holobiont resistance and resilience

Abstract

As coral reefs face unprecedented declines driven by thermal stress and the breakdown of coral symbiosis (i.e., coral bleaching), restoration efforts increasingly rely on coral health and resilience rankings. However, seasonal plasticity in symbiosis and holobiont metabolism, along with the presence of cryptic species, can complicate data interpretation. Therefore, quantifying seasonal plasticity in coral physiology and incorporating genetic identification are essential for accurately interpreting and drawing conclusions from trait-based and fitness-based analyses. To test the effect of seasonal and site variation on physiological plasticity we sampled three ecologically dominant genera, Acropora, Pocillopora, and Porites across three lagoon sites (n=15 tagged colonies genus-1 site-1) on the north shore of Moorea French Polynesia in January, March, September, and December of 2020. We identified coral host and intracellular symbiotic Symbiodiniaceae to the highest taxonomic resolution possible and quantified 13 physiological variables within the holobiont. Genetic analyses identified A. pulchra along with cryptic lineages in Pocillopora (P. meandrina, P. tuahiniensis) and Porites (P. evermanni, P. lobata/lutea). A. pulchra was dominated by Durusdinium trenchii and also contained Symbiodinium microadriaticum. Symbiont communities differed between cryptic congeners, with P. meandrina hosting Cladocopium latusorum and P. tuahiniensis hosting Cladocopium pacificum, whereas P. evermanni and P. lobata/lutea both hosted Cladocopium (C15), but each with unique C15 profiles. Weedy taxa such as Acropora and Pocillopora displayed a cycle of symbiont boom and bust in response to seasonally variable light and temperature, likely contributing to the high stress sensitivity of these taxa. In contrast, despite seasonal environmental variability, Porites displayed greater symbiont stability, with temperature--rather than light--serving as the stronger explanatory variable of seasonal variation in host physiology. Increased host biomass under cooler conditions, which provides energy reserves, may serve as an important stabilizing factor in massive Porites well-documented stress resilience. Collectively, our data provide essential evidence of the need for integrative analyses considering baseline physiological states across seasons along with host and symbiont genetics, particularly in light of the plethora of climate change related stress test assays taking place throughout the year across coral taxa with cryptic lineages.