Ecological drivers of social complexity: the role of predation risk and nesting resource in group-living cichlid

Abstract

Understanding how social complexity responds to environmental variation remains a longstanding challenge in evolutionary biology. Here, we investigated the drivers of social complexity using intraspecific social variation across seven locations of the obligatory shell-brooding cichlid Neolamprologus meeli in Lake Tanganyika. We quantified the number of subordinate individuals per female territory and examined the effects of predation risk, shell availability, and their interaction. Social complexity increased with shell availability under high predation risk but showed little association under low predation risk. A field manipulative-experiment further demonstrated that increasing shell availability led to higher juvenile retention, indicating a causal effect of territory quality. In addition, removal of subordinates reduced shell availability, suggesting the feedback between group size and territory maintenance. We also assessed genetic population structure based on nuclear SNPs obtained by MIG-seq and found only weak genetic differentiation among localities, suggesting that the observed social variation is unlikely to simply reflect strong genetic subdivision. Together, these results show that predation risk promotes group living, whereas nesting resource availability constrains its extent. Our study highlights that social complexity emerges from the interaction between macro- and micro-ecological factors, providing a mechanistic understanding of the evolution of social complexity and philopatry.