Comparing faster evolving rplB and rpsC versus SSU rRNA for improved microbial community resolution

Abstract

Many conserved protein-coding core genes are single copy and evolve faster, and thus are more resolving phylogenetic markers than the standard SSU rRNA gene but their use has been precluded by the lack of universal primers. Recent advances in gene targeted assembly methods for large shotgun metagenomes make their use feasible. To evaluate this approach, we compared the variation of two single copy ribosomal protein genes, rplB and rpsC, with the SSU rRNA gene for all completed bacterial genomes in NCBI RefSeq. As expected, among pairwise comparisons of all species that belong to the same genus, 94.9% and 91.0% of the pairs of rplB and rpsC, respectively, showed more variation than did their SSU rRNA gene sequences. We used a gene-targeted assembler, Xander, to assemble rplB and rpsC from shotgun metagenomic data from rhizosphere samples of three crops: corn (annual), and Miscanthus and switchgrass (both perennials). Both protein-coding genes separated all three communities whereas the SSU rRNA gene could only separate the annual from the two perennial communities in ordination analyses. Furthermore, assembled rplB and rpsC yielded significantly higher numbers of OTUs (alpha diversity) than the SSU rRNA gene. These results confirm these faster evolving marker genes offer increased resolution of for comparative microbiome studies.