There is no convincing evidence that Methylobacterium extorquens AM1 can produce N-deoxyschizokinen A

Abstract

It was recently reported that Methylobacterium extorquens AM1 produces the citrate- hydroxamate siderophore N-deoxyschizokinen A, identified by LC-HRMS. Multiple properties were inconsistent with the assignment: the feature eluted far later than the other schizokinen derivatives (17 min versus 6-8 min), a reversed-phase shift larger than a single-hydroxyl difference in a molecule can explain, further its accurate mass deviated from the calculated one by 28 ppm, well outside the error on the co-analyzed standards and its diagnostic m/z 105 and 77 fragments suggest a molecule with an aromatic moiety. A replicate comparison of identical samples in plastic versus glass autosampler vials was decisive: the m/z 387 feature was reproducibly present with plastic vials and absent with glass. We therefore conclude that the reported detection of N-deoxyschizokinen A in M. extorquens AM1 is an artifact, and recommend glass-vial and solvent-blank controls, an explicit accurate-mass threshold, and narrow MS/MS isolation when assigning trace siderophore-like features from complex extracts.