Participatory Systems Mapping and Experimental Games to Explore Biosecurity Adoption in Broiler Production in Bangladesh

Abstract

IntroductionAntimicrobial Resistance (AMR) presents a critical public health challenge, particularly in smallholder broiler farming, where antibiotics are often used preventively in the absence of effective biosecurity measures. ObjectiveThis study investigates the adoption of biosecurity practices as a sustainable alternative to antibiotics through Participatory Systems Mapping and Experimental Games. MethodsA participatory mixed-methods study was conducted in southern Bangladesh (September 2024-June 2025). Causal Loop Diagrams (CLDs) were co-created with farmers, dealers, and veterinary officers. Ten broiler farmers from single village were selected via purposive and snowball sampling. Experimental games simulated four production cycles where farmers chose Option A (biosecurity, adopters) or Option B (antibiotics, non-adopters) after several interactive trainings. Key metrics including biosecurity compliance (0-12 scale), mortality, FCR, antibiotic use, outbreak history, and economic outcomes were recorded. ResultsCLD analysis revealed a reinforcing loop of increased antibiotic reliance driven by fear of mortality, and balancing loops involving training, biosecurity practices, and consumer incentives to reduce use. Five farmers chose Option A, and both groups remained stable until Round 4. Adopters had flock sizes of 800-2000 birds (non-adopters, 600-1000; mean for both = 1000), were younger, and more educated compared to non-adopters. At baseline, both groups had similar biosecurity scores (0). Adopters had higher mean outbreaks (2 vs. 1.4), mortality (5.6 vs. 4.2), antibiotic use (3.6 vs. 3), and FCR (1.8 vs. 1.6) compared to non-adopters. By Round 4, adopters improved biosecurity scores by 125%, eliminated outbreaks, reduced mortality by 52.6%, stopped antibiotic use, improved FCR by 13.3%, and gained 71.72% profit per bird compared to non-adopters. Non-adopters, influenced by adopters, increased biosecurity scores by 25%, reducing outbreaks, mortality, antibiotic use, and FCR. Adopters also increased direct sales to consumers, yielding a 10%-16% profit gain per bird each round. ConclusionThis study highlights the successful adoption of biosecurity practices by farmers, replacing antibiotics and improving production outcomes. Farmer-driven adoption of these practices fosters long-term sustainability and supports a healthier planet within the One Health framework.