Unexpectedly high coral heat tolerance at thermal refugia

Marine heatwaves and mass bleaching have led to global declines in coral reefs. Corals can adapt, yet, to what extent local variations in thermal stress regimes influence heat tolerance and adaptive potential remains uncertain. Here we identify persistent local-scale thermal refugia and hotspots among the reefs of a remote Pacific archipelago, based on 36 years of satellite-sensed temperatures. Theory suggests that hotspots should promote coral heat tolerance through acclimatisation and directional selection. While historic patterns of mass bleaching and marine heatwaves align with this expectation, we find a contrasting pattern for a single species, Acropora digitifera, exposed to a marine heatwave experiment. Higher heat tolerance at thermal refugia (+0.7 {degrees}C-weeks) and correlations with other traits suggest that non-thermal selective pressures may also influence heat tolerance. We also uncover widespread heat tolerance variability, indicating climate adaptation potential. Compared to the least-tolerant 10% of the A. digitifera population, the most-tolerant 10% could withstand an additional heat stress of 5.2 and 4.1 {degrees}C-weeks for thermal refugia and hotspots, respectively. Despite expectations, local-scale thermal refugia can harbour higher heat tolerance, and mass bleaching patterns do not necessarily predict species responses. This has important implications for designing climate-smart initiatives to tackle global-scale adaptive management problems.