Multiple stressors in the Anthropocene: Urban evolutionary history modifies sensitivity to the toxic effects of crude oil exposure in killifish

Abstract

Persistence of wild species in human-altered environments is difficult, in part because challenges to fitness are complex when multiple environmental changes occur simultaneously, which is common in the Anthropocene. This complexity is difficult to conceptualize because the nature of environmental change is often highly context specific. A mechanism-guided approach may help to shape intuition and predictions about complexity; fitness challenges posed by co-occurring stressors with similar mechanisms of action may be less severe than for those with different mechanisms of action. We approach these considerations within the context of ecotoxicology because this field is built upon a rich mechanistic foundation. We hypothesized that evolved resistance to one class of common toxicants would afford resilience to the fitness impacts of another class of common toxicants that shares mechanisms of toxicity. Fundulus killifish populations in urban estuaries have repeatedly evolved resistance to persistent organic pollutants including PCBs. Since PCBs and some of the toxicants that constitute crude oil (e.g., high molecular weight PAHs) exert toxicity through perturbation of AHR signaling, we predicted that PCB resistant populations would also be resilient to crude oil toxicity. Common garden comparative oil exposure experiments, including killifish populations with different exposure histories, showed that most killifish populations were sensitive to fitness impacts (reproduction and development) caused by oil exposure, but that fish from the PCB-resistant population were insensitive. Population differences in toxic outcomes were not compatible with random-neutral expectations. Transcriptomics revealed that the molecular mechanisms that contributed to population variation in PAH resilience were shared with those that contribute to evolved variation in PCB resilience. We conclude that the fitness challenge posed by environmental pollutants is effectively reduced when those chemicals share mechanisms that affect fitness. Mechanistic considerations may help to scale predictions regarding the fitness challenges posed by stressors that may co-occur in human-altered environments.