Soil microbiome functions in plant-aphid dynamics are resilient to community restructuring during compost application

Abstract Background: Soil microbiomes play critical roles in plant health and resilience, yet it is still poorly understood how disruptions in local microbial communities, such as during soil management, impact these ecological functions. In this study, we investigated how compost addition, a widely used soil management practice, and microbiome origin influence microbiome-mediated plant resistance to insects. We combined surveys of working organic farms across New York with controlled laboratory experiments, amplicon sequencing, plant-insect bioassays, and mass spectrometry. Results: Compost use was associated with shifts in the relative abundance of 20 fungal and 2 bacterial genera across ten working farms. However, no consistent changes in bacterial or fungal diversity or community structure in fields with compost were observed across the farms. Under controlled conditions using a common compost source, compost increased rhizosphere microbial diversity and significantly altered rhizosphere community structure, including the relative abundance of 6 fungal and 41 bacterial genera. Despite these substantial community-level changes, compost did not affect populations of green peach aphids (Myzus persicae) on kale (Brassica oleracea). Instead, aphid populations and plant salicylic acid concentrations were more strongly associated with microbiome origin, demonstrating that compost can substantially restructure soil and rhizosphere microbial communities without corresponding changes in microbiome-mediated plant resistance to insects. Conclusions: Our findings demonstrate that microbial diversity and compositional responses to management are not necessarily reliable indicators of all microbiome functions. More broadly, this work highlights the importance of local soil microbiome variation in shaping plant-insect interactions and emphasizes the need to link community-level responses to direct functional measurements when evaluating microbiome responses to agricultural management.