Multiple carotenoid-based signals are enhanced despite poor body condition in urban male and female Northern Cardinals (Cardinalis cardinals)

Abstract

If humans aim to sustainably coexist with wildlife, we must understand how our activity impacts the communication systems of urban animal populations. We know much about the effects of anthropogenic noise on bird song, but relatively little about how avian visual signals are affected by urbanization. One way such an effect may occur if urbanization alters the food available to species with color based on carotenoids, which they must obtain from their diet. Over three years, we compared a comprehensive suite of visual signals in male and female Northern Cardinals (Cardinalis cardinals) in a rural and an urban population. We predicted that urban birds would have enhanced carotenoid-based signals as they likely have access to more carotenoids from invasive plants, especially honeysuckle (Lonicera spp.), that thrive in cities. We used reflectance spectrometry, digital image analyses, and avian visual models to quantify hue, saturation, and brightness of chest (male), underwing (female), and bill (male and female) signals. Compared to rural males, urban males had redder chest feathers in one year and redder bills in every year. Urban females had more saturated underwing color than rural females in every year. These color differences were sufficient to be distinguished by the avian visual system. Urbanization did not affect female bill color. Interestingly, urban birds had significantly reduced mass-related body condition compared to rural birds. These results show that both male and female urban birds can display enhanced carotenoid-based signals despite being in relatively poor condition. The consequences of this color enhancement are unknown, but it could affect the information content of the signals and the dynamics of the social and mating systems. These results stand in stark contrast to the predominant trend in birds of decreased color in urban areas and highlight the complex and varied potential effects of urbanization on animal communication.