Coordinated leaf hydraulic thresholds maintain virtually null stomatal safety margins in poplar despite genetic variation and nutrient-induced phenotypic plasticity

The sequence of leaf physiological thresholds underlying plant responses to water deficit is thought to be functionally coordinated; yet, to what extent this coordination is maintained across genotypes and environments remains poorly documented at the intraspecific level. We characterized the sequence of stomatal closure, turgor loss and xylem embolism in the leaves of two genotypes of the riparian species Populus nigra (DRA-038 vs. PG-31) subjected to control, additional nitrogen or additional potassium treatments. Under control conditions, embolism measurements using the optical vulnerability method showed that DRA-038 was more vulnerable than PG-31, in agreement with measurements performed on stems with the reference Cavitron method. Stomatal closure consistently preceded xylem embolism, while bulk leaf turgor loss was typically observed once xylem embolism had already reached 50%. Hydraulic thresholds responded to treatments in a genotype-dependent manner, the intrinsically more vulnerable genotype DRA-038 being typically more plastic. However, despite variations across genotypes and treatments, the trait sequence remained tightly coordinated such that stomatal safety margins (SSMs) remained virtually null. These findings support a strong mechanistic integration of leaf hydraulic thresholds in poplar across genetic units and varying environments, questioning whether to favour intrinsic tolerance or plastic capacities in breeding future drought-tolerant genotypes.