Sign in
GenomicsInsects
Peer-reviewed journal article

Aquatic insects are dramatically underrepresented in genomic research

Scott HotalingiD, Joanna L. KelleyiD, Paul B. FrandseniD

Abstract

Aquatic insects comprise 10% of all insect diversity, can be found on every continent except Antarctica, and are key components of freshwater ecosystems. Yet aquatic insect genome biology lags dramatically behind that of terrestrial insects. If genomic effort was spread evenly, one aquatic insect genome would be sequenced for every [~]9 terrestrial insect genomes. Instead, [~]24 terrestrial insect genomes have been sequenced for every aquatic insect genome. This discrepancy is even more dramatic if the quality of genomic resources is considered; for instance, while no aquatic insect genome has been assembled to the chromosome level, 29 terrestrial insect genomes spanning four orders have. We argue that a lack of aquatic insect genomes is not due to any underlying difficulty (e.g., small body sizes or unusually large genomes) yet it is severely hampering aquatic insect research at both fundamental and applied scales. By expanding the availability of aquatic insect genomes, we will gain key insight into insect diversification and empower future research for a globally important taxonomic group. Simple SummaryAquatic insects comprise 10% of all insect diversity, can be found on every continent except Antarctica, and are key components of freshwater ecosystems. Yet aquatic insect genome biology lags dramatically behind that of terrestrial insects. If genomic effort was spread evenly, one aquatic insect genome would be sequenced for every [~]9 terrestrial insect genomes. Instead, [~]24 terrestrial insect genomes have been sequenced for every aquatic insect genome. We argue that the limited availability of aquatic insect genomes is not due to practical limitations--e.g., small body sizes or overly complex genomes--but instead reflects a lack of research interest. We call for targeted efforts to expand the availability of aquatic insect genomic resources to gain key molecular insight into insect diversification and empower future research.

02 /Specification & Classification

Click any tag to browse matching papers
Citations
46
FWCI
2.52
Field percentile
top 9%

Reproducibility ledger

Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.

Sign in to file a reproducibility report.

Similarity Map
SelectedSame fieldCross-field
THISHotaling '21Sendek '22Gilligan '24Srivathsan '22Malacrino' '21Dworatzek '25
63% semantic matchGenomics
Scott Hotaling, John S. Sproul, Jacqueline Heckenhauer+5 more·Genome Biology and Evolution·Jun 11, 2021· 117 citations