Comparative scototaxis among four honey bee species

Abstract

Honey bees can swim on the water surface toward dark regions, a behavior known as scototaxis that may facilitate escape from water. Although this behavior has been reported in both honey bees and solitary bees, variation among honey bee species remains poorly understood. We compared scototaxis during swimming in four honey bee species representing two nesting types: open-nesting (Apis florea and A. dorsata) and cavity-nesting (A. cerana and A. mellifera). Individual bees were released into a water-filled arena containing a dark sector, and their landing angles were recorded. All species exhibited significant orientation toward the dark sector. However, open-nesting species showed significantly stronger orientation than cavity-nesting species. No significant differences were detected between replicate colonies within species or between species within the same nesting type, whereas differences between nesting types were highly significant. Hierarchical clustering based on orientation strength placed Osmia, a solitary cavity-nesting bee from our previous study, in the same behavioral cluster as the two open-nesting Apis species rather than the cavity-nesting honey bees. We also measured swimming duration, distance, and velocity, but found no consistent differences between nesting types. These results demonstrate substantial interspecific variation in swimming scototaxis. The behavioral clustering is consistent with the hypothesis that strong scototaxis represents an ancestral trait that has been reduced in the derived A. cerana/A. mellifera lineage.