Sensorimotor dynamics differentiate singing and speaking
Alexis L. PracariD, Mattia F. PagnottaiD, David Ricardo Quiroga‐MartineziD, Rableen S. Ghuman, Cong DuiD, Mohammad DastjerdiiD, Jack J. LiniD, Jon Timothy WillieiD, Peter BrunneriD, Nina F. DronkersiD, Robert T. KnightiD
Abstract
Singing and speaking often dissociate clinically--people who stutter can sing fluently, and individuals with aphasia and speech output problems from stroke may express sentences fluently in song--yet the neural mechanisms of this centuries-old clinical phenomenon remain unclear. We recorded intracranial EEG while neurosurgical patients produced matched sentences by singing or speaking, sampling millimeter- and millisecond-scale activity across both hemispheres. During articulation, high-frequency activity (70-150 Hz) lateralized oppositely across behaviors, with right-dominant sensorimotor cortex (SMC) activation for singing and left-dominant activation for speaking. Phase-amplitude coupling revealed that mu-band ([~]10 Hz) phase locally organized HFA in left SMC in a channel-specific, spatially interdigitated architecture preserved across both behaviors. Mu-band synchrony in speaking showed an early left-led pattern, whereas singing exhibited a ramping of synchrony within the left sensorimotor cortex and between the two motor cortices, supporting progressive interhemispheric recruitment. Frequency-domain Granger- Geweke causality revealed that the left primary somatosensory cortex drives both motor cortices at speech onset. In contrast in singing, control over motor cortices relied on both hemispheres. Singing and speaking engage a shared mu-coupled sensorimotor substrate through distinct recruitment dynamics.
02 /Specification & Classification
Click any tag to browse matching papers- Citations
- 1
- Organism
- Assay
- Research Focus
- Approach
Reproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- Listening to speech induces coupling between auditory and motor cortices in an unexpectedly rate-restricted manner
María Florencia Assaneo, David Poeppel·Science AdvancesPeer-reviewed·Feb 2, 2018
- Anatomically distinct cortical tracking of music and speech by slow (1-8Hz) and fast (70-120Hz) oscillatory activity
Sergio Osorio, María Florencia Assaneo·PLoS ONEPeer-reviewed·May 8, 2025
- Oscillatory brain networks in continuous speaking and listening
Omid Abbasi, Nadine Steingräber, … Joachim Groß·PLoS BiologyPeer-reviewed·Jul 21, 2023
- Speech and music recruit frequency-specific distributed and overlapping cortical networks
Noémie te Rietmolen, Manuel R. Mercier, … Daniele Schön·eLifePeer-reviewed·Jul 22, 2024
- High-gamma activity is coupled to low-gamma oscillations in precentral cortices and modulates with movement and speech
Jeffrey Z. Nie, Robert D. Flint, … Marc W. Slutzky·eNeuroPeer-reviewed·Jan 19, 2024
- Neocortical activity tracks syllable and phrasal structure of self-produced speech
Mathieu Bourguignon, Nicola Molinaro, … Xavier De Tiège·bioRxiv·Aug 22, 2019