Precision Confidence Mapping: An approach to determining individualized network topography with limited data
Julian S.B. RamireziD, Robert J. M. HermosilloiD, Julia MoseriD, Gracie J. GrimsrudiD, Erendiz Tarakci, Han H. N. PhamiD, Kate GodfreyiD, Helayna Sjoberg, Vanessa MorganiD, Thomas J. MadisoniD, Timothy O. LaumanniD, Evan M. GordoniD, Nico U.F. DosenbachiD, Kimberly B. WeldoniD, Óscar Miranda-DomíngueziD, Brenden Tervo‐ClemmensiD, Steven M. NelsoniD, Damien A. FairiD
Abstract
Individualized resting-state functional magnetic resonance imaging (rs-fMRI) is increasingly used to guide neuromodulation target selection. However, clinical scans are often short and noisy, and standard pipelines for functional network identification do not provide information about confidence of network assignment. With limited data, unstable network assignments can misdirect stimulation toward off-target regions, making it critical to know which assignments can be trusted. We developed Precision Confidence Mapping (PCM), a bootstrap-based framework that makes this uncertainty explicit and actionable. PCM repeatedly resamples the time series and reruns network detection to estimate how consistently each vertex is assigned to a given network. The resulting confidence maps can be thresholded to exclude less stable regions. We evaluated PCM across scan durations from 5 to 70 minutes using positive predictive value (PPV) as the primary measure of network-assignment precision. PPV quantified the proportion of vertices assigned to a network that received the same label in an independent within-subject 70 minute reference map. Confidence thresholding markedly improved PPV across functional networks, with the largest gains for short scan durations. Compared with standard network assignment, PCM significantly increased agreement with this independent reference. Within-subject agreement remained greater than between-subject agreement, indicating that thresholding preserved individual-specific network topography. These precision gains came with modest reductions in reference-network coverage, particularly at shorter scan durations. This tradeoff may be acceptable for neuromodulation applications that prioritize minimizing off-network assignments. By adding a reliability layer to individualized mapping, PCM supports more cautious and precise neuromodulation targeting under real-world clinical scan constraints.
02 /Specification & Classification
Click any tag to browse matching papers- Citations
- 0
- Assay
- Research Focus
- Approach
Reproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- Feasibility of Precision Functional Mapping in Youth Multi-Echo fMRI Data
Isaac N. Treves, David Pagliaccio, … Hilary A. Marusak·Developmental Cognitive NeurosciencePeer-reviewed·Jul 24, 2026
- A Precision Functional Atlas of Network Probabilities and Individual-Specific Network Topography
Robert J. M. Hermosillo, Lucille A. Moore, … Damien A. Fair·bioRxiv·Jan 12, 2022
- Objective Quality Assessment for Precision Functional MRI Data
Charles J. Lynch, Megan Chang, … Conor M. Liston·NeuronPeer-reviewed·Jun 1, 2026
- Towards Precision Functional Brain Network Mapping in Parkinsons Disease
Jacob Garrett Chernicky, Ally Dworetsky, … Caterina Gratton·NeuroImage ClinicalPeer-reviewed·Dec 19, 2025
- Movie Watching for Individual Functional Brain Network Estimation in Adolescents
Kate Godfrey, Gracie J. Grimsrud, … Steven M. Nelson·bioRxiv·Oct 15, 2026
- Within-Individual Precision Mapping of Brain Networks Exclusively Using Task Data
Jingnan Du, Vaibhav Tripathi, … Randy L. Buckner·NeuronPeer-reviewed·Sep 27, 2025