bioRxivSystems BiologyPreprint
SBMate: A Framework for Evaluating Quality of Annotations in Systems Biology Models
Woosub ShiniD, Joseph L. HellersteiniD, Yuda MunarkoiD, Maxwell Lewis NealiD, David Phillip NickersoniD, Anand RampadarathiD, Herbert M. SauroiD, John H. GennariiD
Abstract
The interests in repurposing and reusing systems biology models have been growing in recent years. Semantic annotations play an important role for this, as they provide crucial information on the meanings and functions of models. However, there are a limited number of tools that evaluate the existence or quality of such annotations. In this paper, we introduce SBMate, a python package that would serve as a framework for evaluating the quality of annotations in systems biology models. Three default metrics are provided: coverage, consistency, and specificity. Coverage checks whether annotations exist in a model. Consistency tests if the annotations are appropriate for the given model element. Finally, specificity represents how detailed the annotations are. We analyzed 1,000 curated models from the BioModels repository using the three metrics and discussed the results. Additional metrics can be easily added to extend the current version of SBMate.
- Citations
- 2
Reproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- An Automated Model Annotation System (AMAS) for SBML Models
Woosub Shin, John H. Gennari, … Herbert M. Sauro·BioinformaticsPeer-reviewed·Oct 24, 2023
- Harmonizing semantic annotations for computational models in biology
M. L. Neal, M. König, … D. Waltemath·bioRxiv·Jan 23, 2018
- TabularQual: A spreadsheet-based format for annotating and curating logical models in SBML-qual
Luna Xingyu Li, Carissa Bleker, … John H. Gennari·bioRxiv·Jun 3, 2026
- Model Annotation and Discovery with the Physiome Model Repository
Dewan Mahabub Sarwar, Reza Kalbasi, … David Phillip Nickerson·BMC BioinformaticsPeer-reviewed·Sep 6, 2019
- BioKC: a collaborative platform for systems biology model curation and annotation
Carlos Vega, Valentin Grouès, … Venkata Satagopam·bioRxiv·Oct 1, 2020
- Verification and reproducible curation of the BioModels repository
Lucian P. Smith, Rahuman S. Malik‐Sheriff, … Herbert M. Sauro·PLoS Computational BiologyPeer-reviewed·Dec 4, 2025