How effective are frogs in regulating crop pest population in a natural multi-trophic system??

Potential of frogs as important natural pest control agents has been highlighted earlier. But the effectiveness of frogs in regulating the pest load in intensive agricultural landscape in a multi-trophic system is not clear. We performed controlled field experiment in paddy field with a varying density (observed in high and low agricultural intensity (AI) areas) of a commonly found frog species and compared the pest and pest predator build-up. The consumption rate of the model amphibian was studied using enclosure experiment. The consequent trophic cascade effect of frogs on both crop pest and other arthropod pest predator was analyzed using mathematical population growth models. Although frogs consumed pests, they could not reduce crop pest abundance. although a lesser frog density found in high AI areas significantly affected the pest predator abundance. Based on the functional response result, mathematical growth models demonstrated that with a constant harvesting factor (Hollings Type II) frogs will always have a negative impact on the beneficial natural enemy population due to intraguild predation thereby limiting its potential as a pest regulator. Our study challenges the notion of frogs as an effective pest control agent and argues that increasing habitat diversity might improve overall biological pest suppression.