Population history and the differential consequences of inbreeding and outcrossing in a plant metapoplation

The phenotypic consequences of inbreeding typically result in a fitness decline proportional to the increase in the inbreeding coefficient, F. This basic assumption of a predictable, inverse relationship between fitness and F has been questioned by a number of empirical studies. We explored the relationship between population history and inbreeding in a metapopulation of the plant Silene latifolia, for which long-term data are available for the historical size and spatial distribution of hundreds of local demes. We used a population genetic analysis to estimate gene flow and bi-parental inbreeding (FIS) in demes with different histories of spatial isolation. A controlled crossing experiment examined whether the effect of inbreeding and outcrossing on fitness-related traits varied with different histories of population size and isolation. Historically isolated demes experienced less gene flow and an increase in FIS, as well as significant inbreeding advantage and outbreeding depression for traits expressed early in life. The causes of variation in the F-fitness relationship among populations will include variance in the distribution of deleterious recessive alleles driven by aspects of population history, including population size, founder effects, gene flow, bi-parental inbreeding, and opportunities for the purging of genetic load. Our findings show that isolation and historical variation in population size likely contribute substantial variation in past inbreeding and the consequences of future inbreeding across the metapopulation.