Neither global nor consistent: a technical comment on the tree diversity-productivity analysis of Liang et al. (2016)

The publication of Liang et al. (2016, Science) seems to demonstrate very clearly that increasing tree species richness substantially increases forest productivity. To combine data from very different ecoregions, the authors constructed a relative measure of tree species richness. This relative richness however confounds plot-level tree species richness and the polar-tropical gradient of tree species richness. We re-analysed their orginal data, computing a regional measure of tree species richness and addressing several other issues in their analysis. We find that there is virtually no effect of relative tree species richness on productivity when computing species richness at the local scale. Also, different ecoregions have very different relationships between tree species richness and productivity. Thus, neither the \"global\" consistency nor the actual effect can be confirmed.