Discriminating bacterial phenotypes at the population and single-cell level: a comparison of flow cytometry and Raman spectroscopy fingerprinting

Abstract

Investigating phenotypic heterogeneity can help to better understand and manage microbial communities. However, characterizing phenotypic heterogeneity remains a challenge, as there is no standardized analysis framework. Several optical tools are available, which often describe properties of the individual cell. In this work, we compare Raman spectroscopy and flow cytometry to study phenotypic heterogeneity in bacterial populations. The growth phase of E. coli populations was characterized using both technologies. Our findings show that flow cytometry detects and quantifies shifts in phenotypic heterogeneity at the population level due to its high-throughput nature. Raman spectroscopy, on the other hand, offers a much higher resolution at the single-cell level (i.e. more biochemical information is recorded). Therefore, it is capable of identifying distinct phenotypic populations when coupled with standardized data analysis. In addition, it provides information about biomolecules that are present, which can be linked to cell functionality. We propose an automated workflow to distinguish between bacterial phenotypic populations using Raman spectroscopy and validated this approach with an external dataset. We recommend to apply flow cytometry to characterize phenotypic heterogeneity at the population level, and Raman spectroscopy to perform a more in-depth analysis of heterogeneity at the single-cell level. ImportanceSingle-cell techniques are frequently applied tools to study phenotypic characteristics of bacterial populations. As flow cytometry and Raman spectroscopy gain popularity in the field, there is a need to understand their advantages and limitations, as well as to create a more standardized data analysis framework. Our work shows that flow cytometry allows to study and quantify shifts at the bacterial population level, but since its resolution is limited for microbial purposes, distinct phenotypic populations cannot be distinguished at the single-cell level. Raman spectroscopy, combined with appropriate data analysis, has sufficient resolving power at the single-cell level, enabling the identification of distinct phenotypic populations. As regions in a Raman spectrum are associated with specific (bio)molecules, it is possible to link these to the cell state and/or its function.