Patient-specific computational mechanics of functional lumbar spine units

Abstract

In the current clinical practice, the diagnosis of spinal disorders and their surgical planning are critically based on imaging data. To complement this data, patient-specific finite element models have been developed and showed to be powerful tools for evaluating spine mechanics. Most of them rely on Computational Tomography (CT) scans - which have a high resolution but are seldom available in routine clinical practice - while only a recent few models are on less invasive Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI). Yet, despite the proliferation of these computational models, encompassing detailed anatomical and functional information, the rheological assumptions they are built upon are based on tissue-sample mechanical response data, which leaves a gap in the quantitative analysis on how such assumptions influence the macroscopic response of a functional spinal unit. Aiming at addressing these shortcomings, the main purpose of this work is to introduce a quantitative computational assessment of the macroscopic impact of commonly adopted rheological models - from linear elasticity to fiber-reinforced nonlinear hyperelasticity - in several loading conditions, focusing on a lumbar unit which is considered as a typical benchmark system. We also propose a reconstruction procedure to accurately describe subject-specific anatomy from MRI data, including the intervertebral disc and its nucleus pulposus. Bones are modeled as linear elastic media, whereas for the AF, we consider three different mechanical models - namely, isotropic linear elasticity and the Holzapfel-Gasser-Ogden model with and without fiber reinforcement. Model verification on an idealized geometry demonstrates numerical consistency, while parametric orthostatic simulations highlight the need for nonlinear formulations to capture anisotropy and strain-stiffening behavior of the intervertebral disc. Then, we carry out flexion, lateral bending, and torsion tests on a subject-specific reconstructed functional unit, for which we provide parametric analysis in terms of momentum magnitude and resulting range of motion. These tests further confirm the need for a nonlinear rheology of the annulus fibrosus and provide a quantitative assessment of the differences between the constitutive laws considered. Moreover, successful comparisons with the literature, in terms of macroscopic deformation under several loading conditions, serve as partial validation for our computational model.