Ecological divergence and post-eclosion brain development shape visual performance during Heliconius speciation
José BorreroiD, Amaia Alcalde AntoniD, Léo LaborieuxiD, Daniel Shane WrightiD, Daniela Lozano-Urrego, Geraldine Rueda-Muñoz, Carolina Pardo‐DíaziD, Camilo A. SalazariD, Stephen Hugh MontgomeryiD, Richard M. MerrilliD
Abstract
Sensory adaptation is increasingly recognized as a key driver of ecological speciation, but how visual system divergence is coordinated across development, and how this translates into behavioral differences, remains poorly understood. The butterfly Heliconius cydno, which inhabits closed-canopy forests, has larger eyes and greater investment in visual brain centers than its sympatric close-relative H. melpomene, which occupies more open forest-edge habitats, suggesting divergent ecological selection on the visual system. However, the behavioral consequences of these visual adaptations, their developmental trajectories, and whether they break down in hybrids is unknown. To address these questions, we combined ecological field data with behavioral assays and deep-learning-assisted segmentation of neuroanatomy. Visual acuity - the ability to resolve spatial detail - was higher in H. cydno, consistent with its greater ommatidia number, but also increased with age in both species despite no change in external eye morphology. These improvements coincided with the onset of male courtship and female oviposition, suggesting that early adult neurodevelopment shapes visual performance and may support the demands of reproduction. Brain morphology showed species-specific trajectories of post-eclosion optic lobe growth that broadly paralleled increases in acuity and were accompanied by ongoing neurogenesis in the adult optic lobes. While hybrids exhibited intermediate visual acuity, relationships among different components of the visual system were disrupted in hybrids. Together, these results show that ommatidia number alone cannot explain variation in visual acuity, and highlight how coordinated sensory evolution, and its breakdown in hybrids, may contribute to divergence during the early stages of speciation. Significance StatementAdaptation of sensory systems is increasingly recognized as a key driver of species formation, but it is unclear how these systems develop and shape behavioral differences. Using closely related Heliconius butterflies adapted to different light environments, we show that visual acuity improves during early adulthood through neural development, despite no change in eye structure. This maturation coincides with the onset of reproductive behaviors and is accompanied by growth and neurogenesis in visual brain regions. In hybrids, coordination among sensory traits breaks down, resulting in intermediate visual performance. These results show that sensory development is critical for behavioral adaptation and suggest that its integration contributes to the maintenance of species boundaries.
02 /Specification & Classification
Click any tag to browse matching papers- Citations
- 3
- Organism
- Assay
- Research Focus
- Approach
Reproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- Adaptive divergence in the eyes of Heliconius butterflies likely contributes to pre- and post mating isolation
D. S. Wright, J. Rodriguez-Fuentes, … R. M. Merrill·bioRxiv·Oct 26, 2023
- Adaptation in the eye and brain contributes to species divergence in visual perception in Heliconius butterflies
Daniel Shane Wright, José Borrero, … Richard M. Merrill·bioRxiv·Aug 28, 2026
- Repeated evolution of reduced visual investment at the onset of ecological speciation in high-altitude Heliconius butterflies.
David F Rivas-Sánchez, Jake Morris, … Stephen H. Montgomery·Evolution LettersPeer-reviewed·May 21, 2025
- Neural divergence and hybrid disruption between ecologically isolated Heliconius butterflies
S. H. Montgomery, M. Rossi, … R. M. Merrill·bioRxiv·Jul 1, 2020
- Adaptive divergence in brain composition between ecologically distinct incipient species
Stephen H. Montgomery, Richard M. Merrill·bioRxiv·Mar 10, 2016
- Weighting of sensory cues reflect changing patterns of visual investment during ecological divergence in Heliconius butterflies.
José Borrero, Elisa Mogollon Perez, … Richard M. Merrill·Biology LettersPeer-reviewed·Oct 1, 2024