Domain-general computational integration in the Sense of Agency
Amir HardufiD, Ophir NetzeriD, Oz Mashiah, Adam ZaideliD, Roy SalomoniD
Abstract
The Sense of Agency (SoA), the experience of being in control of ones own actions, is thought to emerge from the comparison of internal sensorimotor predictions with afferent feedback. Classical comparator models treat SoA as arising from a prediction-feedback comparison. Volitional action likely engages multiple forward models that predict distinct features of an outcome, such as its timing and spatial trajectory. Whether prediction errors arising from these distinct forward models are integrated into a domain-general representation of agency, and if so by what computational logic, remains unresolved. We addressed this question using a Virtual Reality reaching task. Participants observed a virtual hand replicating their movements while we independently manipulated two sensorimotor domains: temporal delay and spatial angle deviation, in isolation and in factorial combinations. After each trial, participants made an SoA judgment. We examined whether SoA responses show computational hallmarks of integration between different features of sensorimotor prediction. Specifically, we pre-registered three computational models (Multiplicative, Minimum, and Mean) and compared their fit to per-trial responses. Across an exploratory sample (N = 16) and a pre-registered replication (N = 38), SoA declined monotonically with conflict magnitude in both domains. Critically, a Multiplicative integration rule consistently outperformed the Minimum and Mean rules. These results provide direct evidence for domain-general integration between prediction errors in SoA, governed by a multiplicative computational logic.
02 /Specification & Classification
Click any tag to browse matching papersReproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- The Body Knows Better: Sensorimotor signals reveal "Suboptimal" inference of the Sense of Agency in the human mind
Asaf Applebaum, Ophir Netzer, … Roy Salomon·CognitionPeer-reviewed·Oct 24, 2024
- A Bayesian psychophysics model of sense of agency
Roberto Legaspi, Taro Toyoizumi·Nature CommunicationsPeer-reviewed·Sep 18, 2019
- Self-agency built with sensorimotor processing: Decoding self-other action attribution in the human brain
Ryu Ohata, Tomohisa Asai, … Hiroshi Imamizu·bioRxiv·Nov 30, 2018
- Neural Correlates of the Embodied Sense of Agency
Amit Regev Krugwasser, Reina van der Goot, … Roy Salomon·bioRxiv·Sep 6, 2024
- Judgments of agency are affected by sensory noise without recruiting metacognitive processing
Marika Constant, Roy Salomon, Elisa Filevich·eLifePeer-reviewed·Jan 20, 2022
- A Unified Neurocomputational Framework for Closed-Loop Motor Control and Sense of Agency
Johannes S Nieuwenhuis, Silvestro Micera, Tommaso Bertoni·bioRxiv·Sep 16, 2026