Resting-state EEG recorded with gel-based versus consumer dry electrodes: spectral characteristics and across-device correlations

Abstract

Recordings of electroencephalographic (EEG) rhythms and their analyses have been instrumental in basic Neuroscience, clinical diagnostics, and the field of brain-computer interfaces (BCIs). While in the past such measurements have been conducted mostly in laboratory settings, recent advancements in dry electrode technology pave way to a broader range of consumer and medical application because of their greater convenience compared to gel-based electrodes. Here we conducted resting-state EEG recordings in two groups of healthy participants using three dry-electrode devices, the Neiry Headband, the Neiry Headphones and the Muse Headband, and one standard gel electrode-based system, the NVX. We examined signal quality for various spatial and spectral ranges which are essential for cognitive monitoring and consumer applications. Distinctive characteristics of signal quality were found, with the Neiry Headband showing sensitivity in low-frequency ranges and replicating the modulations of delta, theta and alpha power corresponding to the eyes-open and eyes-closed conditions, and the NVX system performing well in capturing high-frequency oscillations. The Neiry Headphones were more prone to low-frequency artifacts compared to the Neiry Headband, yet recorded modulations in alpha power and had a strong alignment with the NVX at higher frequencies. The Muse Headband had several limitations in signal quality. We suggest that while dry-electrode technology appears to be appropriate for the EEG rhythm-based applications the potential benefits of these technologies in terms of ease of use and accessibility should be carefully weighted against the capacity of each concrete system.