Evidence that Dogs Can Use Temporal Difference in Odorant Arrival to Discriminate Odorant Mixtures

In turbulent environments, odorants from different sources arrive at different times, potentially providing cues for odor source segregation. In several invertebrate species, short differences in odorant onset enable freely moving animals to discriminate odorant mixtures. In vertebrates, however, studies of sensitivity to odorant onset asynchrony have been conducted under highly constrained sampling conditions, such as with odor delivery tightly coupled to respiration. In this study, we investigated whether domestic dogs could detect odorant onset asynchrony in odorant mixtures under conditions that preserve key features of natural odor sampling. Dogs performed a discrimination task in which odor stimuli were presented as ongoing pulse trains that began independently of animal behavior, avoiding artificial synchronization of odor delivery with sniff cycles. Dogs were trained to discriminate between mixtures of two odorants with synchronous onsets and mixtures with asynchronous onsets. Of the dogs trained, one was able to discriminate odorant onset asynchronies as short as 633 ms. Dogs also displayed sensitivity to auditory stimulus onset asynchrony, discriminating auditory asynchronies as short as 30 ms. These results provide the first demonstration of temporal sensitivity in canine olfaction and the first evidence that vertebrates can use odorant onset asynchrony under conditions that permit free odor sampling.