Divergent Behavioral Responses to Resource Limitations by Honey Bees, Bumble Bees, and Mason Bees

Resource limitation is a central ecological phenomenon shaping pollinator behavior, reproduction, and community dynamics. Many studies have looked at these interactions, but few have forced competition and explored species-specific responses. Here, we experimentally evaluated behavioral and reproductive responses of honey bees (Apis mellifera), bumble bees (Bombus impatiens), and mason bees (Osmia bruneri) in controlled single and multispecies foraging environments. Across all treatments, each species exhibited distinct forms of behavioral compensation when exposed to increased interspecific competition. Apis mellifera reduced the number of foraging events in mixed species cages yet showed variation in colony growth. B. impatiens increased foraging effort when co-foraging with other species, but this heightened activity did not translate into increased colony growth. O. bruneri maintained consistent foraging effort across treatments but exhibited reduced reproduction and a marked shift in floral host use, switching from preferred species (Phacelia tanacetifolia and Melilotus alba) to less-preferred alternatives (Collinsia grandiflora and Trifolium incarnatum) when competing with social bees. Regardless of compensatory behaviors, all three species demonstrated reduced reproductive success under competitive conditions. Our findings underscore the importance of evaluating interspecific competition when placing managed bees in natural or semi-natural habitats to avoid inadvertently stressing wild or managed bee populations and taking into consideration species-specific responses in addition to community level responses to competition.