Size matters, so does condition: the use of a body condition index reveals the costs and benefits of structural body size in an insect.

Abstract

O_LIInsects are core actors for the balance of many earth ecosystems, as well as an alternative source of food and feed with a low ecological footprint. A comprehensive understanding of their life history requires reliable tools. Body condition constitutes the amount of energy reserves available to a fitness trait after maintenance costs have been accounted for. Body condition is standardly estimated using Body Condition Indexes (BCIs) in vertebrates. In insects the relevance of BCIs is frequently questioned on the basis that they might not accurately reflect neither energy reserves nor fitness.. However, to date no study has tested whether the very concept of body condition is relevant in insects, i.e. whether BCIs accurately reflect the relative energy reserves allocated to fitness traits. C_LIO_LIWe propose that the relevance of using BCIs in insects depends on whether their structural size has a fitness cost. If on the contrary insects only benefit from a larger body size, a simple measurement of body size or mass will predict fitness, but not a BCI. We experimentally manipulated food availability at the larval and adult stage and used total fecundity of females as a fitness proxy of Tenebrio molitor, an important model in physiology, ecology and evolution, and one of the first insects to be considered as a source of food and feed. C_LIO_LIOur results support three key assumptions of the relevance of BCIs in insects: (i) a valid BCI correlated with energy reserves corrected for a given size (i.e. relative energy reserves) and not with absolute measures of energy reserves; (ii) both structural size and body condition positively predict different components of fitness; and, (iii) the effect of body condition was dependent on resource availability, whereby its effect was only apparent and large when food was unrestricted at the larval stage and restricted at the adult stage. C_LIO_LIOverall we demonstrate the relevance of using BCIs in insects. Their use should be generalized to improve fitness readouts in evolution, ecological and physiological studies, as well as improve their husbandry for commercial purposes. C_LI