The structural context of mutations in proteins predicts their effect on antibiotic resistance

Abstract

In Mycobacterium tuberculosis, a prevalent and deadly pathogen, resistance to antibiotics evolves primarily through non-synonymous mutations in proteins. Sequence-based analyses are currently used to understand the genetic basis of antibiotic resistance, either via genotype-phenotype association, or via signals of convergent evolution. These methods focus on primary sequence and often neglect other biological signals such as protein structural information. We hypothesize that integrating the structural context of mutations improves the prediction of effects on function and phenotype. We curate high confidence structural annotations for the M. tuberculosis proteome from 1,371 crystallography and 2,316 AlphaFold predictions, and combine the structures with mutations from over 31,000 clinical M. tuberculosis isolates. We demonstrate that mutations in proteins known to cause resistance are clustered in 3D space, even in proteins where inactivating mutations at any position are thought to cause resistance. We develop a statistic to search the M. tuberculosis proteome for signal of clustered mutations, finding over 450 proteins that display this signal, many of which have a known relationship with antibiotic resistance. We show that a supervised classifier trained on 3D distance to known resistance sites alone has an F1 score of 94.6% at classifying mutations as resistance-conferring across proteins. This work demonstrates that protein structure provides useful information for categorizing which variants may cause antibiotic resistance, even when the majority of structures are AI-predicted.