An Eligibility-Aware Pipeline for Robust ITS Diagnostics in Fungi: A Cacao Case Study with Generalizable Rules

Accurate fungal ITS diagnostics rely on public sequence archives, but heterogeneous record lengths, especially frequent truncation before the LSU/28S segment, cause naive in silico benchmarking to conflate primer performance with database incompleteness. To resolve this persistent "denominator error," we present an open and fully reproducible "eligibility-aware" framework. Our pipeline first establishes eligibility by confirming both primer sites are present before applying bench-realistic performance rules, including a strict penalty for 3-terminal mismatches. It further provides mechanistic insights by analyzing binding-site conservation and uses a rarefaction-based approach to guide efficient quality control as databases grow. We demonstrate the frameworks utility using the cacao pathosystem, a context where rapid differentiation of the fungal pathogen Moniliophthora from symptomatically similar oomycetes is critical. The result is a robust, field-ready diagnostic decision tree operable under a single touchdown (TD) PCR program. By providing a transparent and barcode-agnostic template, our eligibility-aware approach offers a significant methodological advance for designing and validating molecular assays in mycology and beyond.