Gonadal sex and sex chromosomes each contribute to sexually dimorphic gene expression in threespine stickleback

Many taxa have evolved heteromorphic sex chromosomes like the XY system found in mammals. In additional to the sex determination gene which directs development of the gonad into an ovary or testis, sex chromosomes can have drastically different gene content, leading to substantial genetic differences between genetic males and females beyond their gonad identity. Studying the effects of these genetic differences is challenging, as the sex chromosomes and sex determination gene are inherited together, so the effects of genetic differences between the X and Y cannot be easily isolated from the hormonal differences produced by the ovary and testis. The threespine stickleback fish has a heteromorphic XY sex chromosome system and a wide range of well documented sex differences in morphology and behaviors, including complex mating behaviors and male-only parental care. Through genetic manipulation of amhy, the newly identified sex determination gene in threespine stickleback, we are able to generate gonadal males and females with either the XX or XY sex chromosome complement and analyze the separate effects of gonadal sex and sex chromosome complement on sexually dimorphic gene expression. We find that sex chromosomes have a larger effect on gene expression than gonadal sex in somatic tissues, while gonadal sex has a larger effect on expression in the gonads. We also find that the X and Y chromosomes are enriched for genes which show differential expression between females and males. Our findings demonstrate the significant biological impact of sex chromosomes outside of primary sex determination and showcase the utility of the threespine stickleback for studying the genetic basis of sex differences.