Accounting for DNA Recovery and Cell Culturability Enhances Quantitative Compatibility of Molecular and Legiolert Assays for Legionella pneumophila

Abstract

Disagreement between molecular and culture-based assays for Legionella pneumophila detection is widely reported, yet comparisons have largely been based on direct assay-derived concentrations or binary positive/negative outcomes. However, it remains unclear whether molecular-culture disagreement reflects concentration-level incompatibility or unaccounted methodological and physiological differences related to DNA recovery and cell culturability. In this study, we also observed disagreement between molecular and Legiolert assays in source and finished drinking water samples collected from eight full-scale drinking water systems across the United States. Molecular thresholds adjusted for DNA recovery and cell culturability only partially resolved these discrepancies. We therefore developed a probabilistic Monte Carlo framework that incorporates sample-specific DNA recovery and cell culturability to evaluate the quantitative consistency of culturable L. pneumophila concentrations estimated by molecular and Legiolert assays. Quantitatively consistent and inconsistent samples occurred across both binary concordant and discordant classifications, demonstrating that positive/negative agreement poorly reflects concentration-level comparability. Overall, molecular and Legiolert assays showed strong quantitative consistency once sample-specific DNA recovery and cell culturability were considered. A small proportion of persistent inconsistencies at specific sampling sites, coupled with atypical microbial indicators, suggest that sample heterogeneity likely contributed to the remaining discrepancies. These findings demonstrate that integrating DNA recovery and cell culturability enhanced quantitative consistency between molecular and Legiolert assays and supports the use of molecular methods as rapid quantitative tools to complement culture-based L. pneumophila monitoring. SynopsisAccounting for DNA recovery and cell culturability revealed broad quantitative compatibility between molecular and Legiolert assays for Legionella pneumophila in drinking water. TOC O_FIG O_LINKSMALLFIG WIDTH=200 HEIGHT=88 SRC="FIGDIR/small/739452v2_ufig1.gif" ALT="Figure 1"> View larger version (26K): org.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@1e01cdcorg.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@86bbc2org.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@190fc66org.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@1aa9ec8_HPS_FORMAT_FIGEXP M_FIG C_FIG