Benchmarking Docking Protocols for GPCR Allosteric Modulators

Abstract

G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) allosteric modulators (AMs) offer significant therapeutic advantages over orthosteric drugs, yet structure-based virtual screening lacks validated protocols accounting for the conformational complexity of GPCR allosteric sites. We benchmark docking protocols using PDB experimental structures and structural ensembles derived from Gaussian accelerated Molecular Dynamics (GaMD) simulations across four Class A GPCRs (including the muscarinic M2 and M4 receptors, the {beta}2-adrenergic receptor, and the C-C chemokine receptor type 2) with four programs (Glide HTVS, AutoDock Vina, DOCK3.8, and Boltz-2) against experimentally validated modulator libraries and property-matched decoys. GaMD ensemble docking improved early AM enrichment across all four targets under at least one program. Glide ensemble docking was the only protocol to consistently improve early AM recovery across all four targets, ranking known actives almost exclusively within the top 0.5% of compounds at CCR2 and improving M2R active recovery nearly 9-fold relative to the PDB structure. GaMD free-energy landscape topology governed ensemble re-ranking strategy selection: population-skewed landscapes favored top binding energy ranking (BEmin) while flat, multi-populated landscapes favored average binding energy ranking (BEavg), and at targets with dominant low-energy states, a single GaMD cluster matched or exceeded full ensemble or PDB performance. Taking the union of top percentile hits identified by both ensemble re-ranking methods, BEmin / BEavg, maximizes chemical diversity at the earliest percentiles. Program-specific scaffold recovery biases further motivated a consensus BEmin / BEavg approach to maximize hit diversity. The Boltz-2 deep-learning program showed minimal sensitivity to GaMD templates and underperformed conventional docking, suggesting its affinity predictions complement rather than replace physics- and empirical-based docking approaches for GPCR AM screening.