medRxivGenetic & Genomic MedicinePreprint
EpiSignaLR: an open resource for genome-wide episignature analysis from methylation-aware short- and long-read sequencing
Sophia B GibsoniD, Miranda Pg Zalusky, Joy GoffenaiD, Elizabeth J. Hamlin, Ruby Lamb, Jenna R. RosinskiiD, Trent M. PralliD, Zachary B. AndersoniD, Sophie H. R. StorziD, Angela L MilleriD, Yuwei ShiiD, Kristina LankoiD, David Mulder, Yaoqing SheniD, Kim LensingiD, Martin ElferinkiD, Samantha A. Schrier VerganoiD, Monica Hsiung WojcikiD, Koen L.I. van GasseniD, William T. GibsoniD, Steven J.M. JonesiD, Tahsin Stefan BarakatiD, Danny E. MilleriD
Abstract
BackgroundEpisignatures, disorder-specific patterns of genome-wide DNA methylation, are established for more than 100 Mendelian conditions and help resolve variants of uncertain significance and evaluate unsolved cases. Current clinical testing approaches typically use data generated by methylation arrays, which require a specific assay and limit discovery to the probe set of the array. Long-read and Illumina 5-base genome sequencing measure CpG methylation alongside genetic variation, raising the possibility of folding episignature analysis into a single genome-wide test. MethodsWe sequenced individuals with SETD1B-related neurodevelopmental disorder, Kabuki syndrome, or Kleefstra syndrome, along with controls, using Oxford Nanopore Technologies (ONT), PacBio HiFi, or Illumina 5-base whole-genome sequencing. We identified differentially methylated regions (DMRs) directly from ONT methylation data and built classifiers using a nested cross-validation framework. ResultsWe identified 143 DMRs for SETD1B-related neurodevelopmental disorder (SETD1B-NDD), 20 for Kabuki syndrome, and 23 for Kleefstra syndrome; 15 to 26% of the DMRs across the three signatures contained no array probe(s). Cross-validated classifiers ranked every case above every control for all three conditions, and the final classifiers called all but one held-out case correctly, with the remaining case, which carries a KMT2D missense variant, as indeterminate. At two outside sites, the classifier for SETD1B-NDD correctly categorized seven out of seven cases. Principal component analysis reveals most PacBio and Illumina 5-base genomes cluster with ONT genomes from the same condition. One PacBio control fell between the other controls and the Kabuki cases, whereas the ONT and 5-base genomes for the same individual grouped with controls, suggesting platform-specific methylation differences that the current training cohort is too small to fully account for. ConclusionsEpisignatures can be derived directly from sequencing data and applied across platforms. EpiSignaLR is an open workflow that combines the three ONT-derived classifiers with 34 published array-derived signatures. Developing robust sequencing-derived episignatures will require larger cohorts per condition and openly shared, platform-matched methylation data.
- organism: human
- assay: DNA methylation
- assay: whole-genome sequencing
- research focus: differential expression
- approach: statistical model
- Citations
- 0
Reproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- Nanopore sequencing-based episignature detection
Mathilde Geysens, Benjamin Huremagic, … Joris Robert Vermeesch·medRxiv·Apr 19, 2024
- Synthetic epigenomes for open cross-platform episignature classifiers
Federico Ferraro, Mark Drost, … Dmitrijs Rots·medRxiv·Mar 28, 2025
- Diagnostic Utility of Genome-wide DNA Methylation Analysis in Genetically Unsolved Developmental and Epileptic Encephalopathies and Refinement of a CHD2 Episignature
Christy W. LaFlamme, Cassandra Rastin, … Heather C. Mefford·Nature CommunicationsPeer-reviewed·Aug 6, 2024
- Episignatures stratifying ADNP syndrome show modest correlation with phenotype
Michael S. Breen, Paras Garg, … Silvia De Rubeis·bioRxiv·Apr 1, 2020
- An Unsupervised Learning Method for Disease Classification Based on DNA Methylation Signatures
Mohammad Firouzi, Andrei L. Turinsky, … Michael Brudno·bioRxiv·Dec 10, 2018
- Detection of outlier methylation from bisulfite sequencing data with novel Bioconductor package BOREALIS
Gavin R. Oliver, Garrett Jenkinson, … Eric W. Klee·bioRxiv·May 19, 2022