Purging of inbreeding depression does not eliminate environmental variation in reproductive onset

Abstract

Many simultaneous hermaphrodites use selfing for reproductive assurance only when outcrossing opportunities are limited, owing to inbreeding depression in selfed progeny. However, scenarios that enforce substantial selfing (such as during recolonisation) can rapidly select for a high selfing propensity, a shift in mating system that is expected to eliminate both inbreeding depression and the delayed reproductive onset under selfing that is typically associated with it. We tested these predictions in the flatworm Macrostomum hystrix, using a line derived from an outcrossing population that had been subjected to enforced selfing for multiple generations followed by several years of relaxed selection. As predicted, isolated individual forced to self and individuals with constant partner access (i.e. outcrossing opportunities) did not differ in reproductive onset nor in inbreeding depression estimated through offspring survival. However, a third treatment group that provided intermittent partner access (to allow outcrossing but minimise potential competition effects) showed a different pattern: no inbreeding depression in offspring but a substantially accelerated reproductive onset. Whilst our results thus support the effective purging of inbreeding depression and increased selfing propensity under enforced selfing, we suggest that cues of an unstable social or physical environment nevertheless exert a major influence on reproductive timing.