No Cost of Complexity in Bacteriophages Adapting to a Complex Environment

Abstract

A longstanding prediction in evolutionary biology is that organisms experience a so-called \"cost of complexity\" manifested as a decreasing rate of adaptation in populations as organisms or selective environments become increasingly complex. This theory assumes the ubiquity of antagonistic pleiotropy, or tradeoffs in fitness, for mutations affecting multiple traits or phenotypes. A particular manifestation of antagonism thought to be at play in adaptive dynamics involves the relationship between viral growth rate and capsid stability, an interaction that may impede the adaptation of viral pathogens to novel hosts and environments. Here, we present a comparison of the genetics of adaptation for populations of bacteriophages undergoing complete adaptive walks under both simple and complex selective conditions, with complexity being determined by the number of traits under directional selection. We found no evidence for a long-term cost of complexity in viruses experiencing complex selection, with on average at least as great a rate of adaptation under more complex conditions, and rampant evidence for synergistic, rather than antagonistic, pleiotropy. The lack of evident tradeoffs between multiple phenotypes implies that emerging pathogens may be able to improve their growth in many different hosts or environments simultaneously and to do so at a faster rate than previously anticipated.