Psychophysical validation of calibrated white-noise and tuned-noise auditory masks for transcranial focused ultrasound

Abstract

Auditory confounds have proven to be a major hurdle in the elucidation of veridical neuromodulation effects with transcranial ultrasound stimulation (TUS). Auditory noise masks are an essential method to reduce the audibility of TUS and have shown promise in several studies. Here we describe a novel approach for design, calibration, and psychometric validation of auditory noise masks to reduce the perceptibility of TUS. White noise masks and spectrum-tuned masks matched to a TUS protocol that generates highly salient auditory costimulation (487.5 Hz pulse repetition frequency, 10% duty cycle, 68 W/cm2 pulse-peak average intensity, 500 kHz acoustic frequency) were generated, and dB(A) levels were calibrated with an artificial ear. The masker levels needed to reduce TUS detection performance in a two-interval forced choice task were determined with an adaptive QUEST+ staircase in 20 neurotypical participants. Detection performance of this highly salient TUS protocol was driven to near chance performance (<55%) in 17/20 participants with white-noise and 18/20 participants with spectrum-tuned noise. However, high masker levels approaching safety limits were needed to render TUS inaudible for the majority of participants, indicating the need for formal masker calibration for these TUS settings. Additionally, against expectation the spectrum-tuned masker did not significantly outperform the white-noise masker, suggesting that perceptibility of TUS auditory costimulation does not lawfully follow the sound expected from its pulse envelope and the known spectrum of human hearing.