Susceptibility of Klebsiella pneumoniae Clinical Isolates in Biofilms to Antibiotics and Assessment of Secondary Drug Effects

Abstract

Biofilms pose a significant challenge to antimicrobial therapy. Bacteria in biofilms differ from planktonic counterpart in their altered metabolism, collective behavior, protective role of extracellular matrix and diversified microbial subpopulations. These attributions significantly influence bioavailability and activity of antibiotics. The presence of bacterial aggregates during acute infections expands the problem to many other conditions previously not discussed in the biofilm context. Klebsiella pneumoniae is a leading cause of life-threatening hospital-acquired infections and is included in the WHO Bacterial Priority Pathogens List due to increasing antimicrobial resistance. The combination of antimicrobial resistance and the ability to form biofilms severely limits the efficacy of antibiotic treatments. In this study, we investigated the in vitro susceptibility of mature biofilms to 13 antimicrobials of K. pneumoniae clinical isolates from a single hospital. The resistance profiles of the local clinical isolates were consistent with the global epidemiology of K. pneumoniae. Minimal biofilm eradication concentrations (MBEC) for mature biofilms were defined with two assays (biomass and metabolic activity measurements) and brought into relation with susceptibility breakpoints and plasma (Cmax). Colistin sulfate, tigecycline, cephalosporins and combination of imipenem with cilastatin were the most potent biomass eradicators, while suppression of metabolic activity was barely reachable. Moreover, we observed a notable increase in metabolic activity upon exposure to sub-MBEC concentrations of antibiotics. Finally, our data broach a subject of antibiotic prioritization with respect to biofilm tolerance. IMPORTANCEThis study addresses the critical gap between standard antibiotic susceptibility testing and the tolerance of biofilm and microbial aggregates during infections caused by K. pneumoniae. By systematically evaluating mature biofilms from a significant number of clinical isolates, we demonstrate that colistin and tigecycline show potent activity against both biofilm biomass and metabolic activity, whereas cephalosporins primarily reduce biomass without effectively suppressing bacterial metabolism, and other drugs have only weak effects on biofilms at clinically achievable concentrations. Furthermore, the alarming observation that sub-inhibitory biofilm eradication concentration (sub-MBEC) of antibiotic can paradoxically increase the metabolic activity of biofilms highlights a potential risk factor for therapy failure and resistance development. Our findings contribute to the necessary evidence base for prioritizing existing antibiotics in the limited armamentarium against biofilm-forming K. pneumoniae.