The Journal of PhysiologyNeurosciencePeer-reviewed journal article
Flexible Control of Motor Units: Is the Multidimensionality of Motor Unit Manifolds a Sufficient Condition?
Francois DernoncourtiD, Simon AvrilloniD, Tijn Logtens, Thomas CattagniiD, Dario FarinaiD, François HugiD
Abstract
Understanding flexibility in the neural control of movement requires identifying the distribution of common inputs to the motor units. In this study, we identified large samples of motor units from two lower limb muscles: the vastus lateralis (VL; up to 60 motor units/participant) and the gastrocnemius medialis (GM; up to 67 motor units/participant). First, we applied a linear dimensionality reduction method to assess the dimensionality of the manifolds underlying the motor unit activity. We subsequently investigated the flexibility in motor unit control under two conditions: sinusoidal contractions with torque feedback, and online control with visual feedback on motor unit firing rates. Overall, we found that the activity of GM motor units was effectively captured by a single latent factor defining a unidimensional manifold, whereas the VL motor units were better represented by three latent factors defining a multidimensional manifold. Despite this difference in dimensionality, the recruitment of motor units in the two muscles exhibited similarly low levels of flexibility. Using a spiking network model, we tested the hypothesis that dimensionality derived from factorization does not solely represent descending cortical commands but is also influenced by spinal circuitry. We demonstrated that a heterogeneous distribution of inputs to motor units, or specific configurations of recurrent inhibitory circuits, could produce a multidimensional manifold. This study clarifies an important debated issue, demonstrating that while motor unit firings of a non-compartmentalised muscle can lie in a multidimensional manifold, the central nervous system may still have limited capacity for flexible control of these units. Key pointsO_LITo generate movement, the central nervous system distributes both excitatory and inhibitory inputs to the motor units. C_LIO_LIThe level of flexibility in the neural control of these motor units remains a topic of debate with significant implications for identifying the smallest unit of movement control. C_LIO_LIBy combining experimental data and in silico models, we demonstrated that the activity of a large sample of motor units from a single muscle can be represented by a multidimensional linear manifold; however, these units show very limited flexibility in their recruitment. C_LIO_LIThe dimensionality of the linear manifold may not directly reflect the dimensionality of descending inputs but could instead relate to the organisation of local spinal circuits. C_LI
- organism: human
- assay: electronic health records
- research focus: dimensionality reduction
- approach: statistical model
- Citations
- 12
- FWCI
- 2.66
- Field percentile
- top 10%
Reproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- The volitional control of individual motor units is constrained within low-dimensional neural manifolds by common inputs
Julien Rossato, Simon Avrillon, … François Hug·Journal of NeurosciencePeer-reviewed·Jul 1, 2024
- Networks of common inputs to motor neurons of the lower limb reveal neural synergies that only partly overlap with muscle innervation
François Hug, Simon Avrillon, … Dario Farina·bioRxiv·Oct 13, 2021
- The control and training of single motor units in isometric tasks are constrained by a common synaptic input signal
Mario Bräcklein, Jaime Ibáñez, … Dario Farina·eLifePeer-reviewed·Jun 7, 2022
- Flexible neural control of motor units
Najja J. Marshall, Joshua I. Glaser, … Mark M. Churchland·Nature NeurosciencePeer-reviewed·Oct 10, 2022
- Rigid Control of Motor Unit Firing Rates in the Human Tibialis Anterior Muscle Persists during Neurofeedback
Meng‐Jung Lee, Patrick Ofner, … Carsten Mehring·Journal of NeurophysiologyPeer-reviewed·Apr 10, 2026
- Interfacing Spinal Motor Units in Non-Human Primates Identifies a Principal Neural Component for Force Control Constrained by the Size Principle
Alessandro Del Vecchio, Rachael HA Jones, … Stuart N. Baker·Journal of NeurosciencePeer-reviewed·Aug 23, 2022