bioRxivCell Biology
An approach for accelerated isolation of genetically manipulated cell clones with reduced clonal variability
Abstract
Genomic editing methods, such as the CRISPR/Cas9 system, are routinely used to study gene function in somatic cells. Due to the heterogeneity of mutations, it is necessary to purify cell clones grown in high dilution until colony formation, which can be a time consuming process. Here we tested a modified approach in which we seeded cells in high dilution, together with non-edited carrier cells. As a comparison, cells were also grown in high dilution with conditioned medium from a high density culture. When using carrier cells or conditioned medium, the formation of cell colonies is accelerated. Additionally, clones grown with carrier cells are more similar to the parental lines in terms of their tumorigenic properties. Surprisingly, key signaling cascades are very divergent between clones isolated from low density cultures, even with conditioned medium, in contrast to clones isolated with carrier cells. Thus, our study uncovers a significant limitation using the common approach of isolating cell clones following genetic modifications and suggests an alternative method that mitigates the problem of heterogeneity of gene expression between clones.\n\nSummary statementWe show here that standard methods of generating cell clones after CRISPR/Cas9 treatment result in highly divergent signaling cascades among clones. We demonstrate here an improved alternative approach.
- organism: human
- research focus: cell type annotation
- research focus: clustering
- research focus: cell-cell communication
- research focus: differential expression
- approach: experimental assay
Reproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- Clonally selected lines after CRISPR/Cas editing are not isogenic
Arijit Panda, Milovan Šuvakov, … Alexej S. Abyzov·The CRISPR JournalPeer-reviewed·Apr 1, 2023
- High-throughput robotic isolation of human iPS cell clones reveals frequent homozygous induction of identical genetic manipulations by CRISPR-Cas9
Gou Takahashi, Minato Maeda, … Yuichiro Miyaoka·Stem Cell Research & TherapyPeer-reviewed·Jun 7, 2025
- Light-Activated Cell Identification and Sorting (LACIS): A New Method to Identify and Select Edited Clones on a Microfluidic Device
A. Mocciaro, T. Roth, … G. Lavieu·bioRxiv·Oct 17, 2017
- Streamlined generation of CRISPR/Cas9-mediated single-cell knockout clones in murine cell lines.
T. Hub, A. Cornean, … R. Medert·bioRxiv·Oct 20, 2023
- Integration of Xeno-Free Single-cell Cloning in CRISPR-mediated DNA Editing of Human iPSCs Improves Homogeneity and Methodological Efficiency of Cellular Disease Modelling
Atefeh Namipashaki, Kealan Pugsley, … Ziarih Hawi·Stem Cell ReportsPeer-reviewed·Nov 16, 2023
- GenEditID: an open-access platform for the high-throughput identification of CRISPR edited cell clones
Ying Xue, Y. C. Loraine Tung, … Florian T. Merkle·bioRxiv·Jun 13, 2019