Experimental evidence of stress-induced critical state in schooling fish

Abstract

How do animal groups dynamically adjust their collective behavior in response to environmental changes is an open and challenging question. Here, we investigate the mechanisms that allow fish schools to tune their collective state under stress, testing the hypothesis that these systems operate near criticality, a state maximizing sensitivity, responsiveness, and adaptability. We combine experiments and data-driven computational modeling to study how group size and stress influence the collective behavior of rummy-nose tetras (Hemigrammus rhodostomus). We quantify the collective state of fish schools using polarization, milling, and cohesion metrics and use a burst-and-coast model to infer the social interaction parameters that drive these behaviors. Our results indicate that group size modulates stress levels, with smaller groups experiencing higher baseline stress, likely due to a reduced social buffering effect. Under stress, fish adjust the strength of their social interactions in a way that leads the group into a critical state, thus enhancing its sensitivity to perturbations and facilitating rapid adaptation. However, large groups require an external stressor to enter the critical regime, whereas small groups are already near this state. Unlike previous studies suggesting that fish adjust their interaction network structure under risk, our results suggest that the intensity of social interactions, rather than network structure, governs collective state transitions. This simpler mechanism reduces cognitive demands while enabling dynamic adaptation. By revealing how stress and group size drive self-organization toward criticality, our study provides fundamental insights into the adaptability of collective biological systems and the emergent properties in animal groups.