Adjusting for systematic technical biases in risk assessment of gene signatures in transcriptomic cancer cohorts
Adrià CaballéiD, Antonio BerengueriD, Camille Stephan‐Otto AttoliniiD
Abstract
In recent years, many efforts in clinical and basic research have focused on finding molecular features of tumor samples with prognostic or classification potential. Among these, the association of the expression of gene signatures with survival probability is of special interest given its relatively direct applicability in the clinic and its power to shed insights into the molecular basis of cancer.\n\nAlthough great efforts have been invested in data processing to control for unknown sources of variability in a gene-wise manner, little is known about the behaviour of gene signatures with respect to the effect of technical variables.\n\nHere we show that the association of signatures with survival may be biased due to technical reasons and propose a simple and low intensive methodology based on correction by expectation under gene randomization. The resulting estimates are centred around zero and ensure correct asymptotic inference. Moreover, our methodology is robust against spurious correlations between global dataset tendencies and clinical outcome.\n\nAll tools (will be soon) available in the \"HRunbiased\" R package as well as processed datasets for colorectal and breast cancer.
02 /Specification & Classification
Click any tag to browse matching papers- Citations
- 5
- Organism
- Assay
- Research Focus
- Approach
Reproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- Gene-signatures for early detection of cancers
Om Prakash, Feroz Khan·bioRxiv·Feb 12, 2023
- Biological misinterpretation of transcriptional signatures in tumour samples can unknowingly undermine mechanistic understanding and faithful alignment with preclinical data
N. C. Fisher, R. Byrne, … P. D. Dunne·bioRxiv·Apr 15, 2022
- signifinder enables the identification of tumor cell states and cancer expression signatures in bulk, single-cell and spatial transcriptomic data
Stefania Pirrotta, Laura Masatti, … Enrica Calura·bioRxiv·Mar 7, 2023
- A novel signature derived from immunoregulatory and hypoxia genes predicts prognosis in liver and five other cancers
W. H. Chang, D. Forde, A. G. Lai·bioRxiv·Oct 14, 2018
- A residual-ratio framework for auditing transcriptomic gene signatures against background expression structure
Ying Zhu, Chenyu Zhang, … Yuda Bi·bioRxiv·Apr 14, 2026
- Avoiding test set bias with rank-based prediction
Prasad Patil, Peirre-Olivier Bachant-Winner, … Jeffrey T Leek·BioinformaticsPeer-reviewed·Mar 18, 2015