Evaluation of Fecal Immunoassays for Canine Echinococcus Infection in China

Abstract

Human echinococcosis is present worldwide but it is in China that prevalence is the highest. Western China and in particular the Tibetan plateau is the region where the burden of echinococcosis is the most important. Dogs are a major carrier of echinococcosis and monitoring the presence of Echinococcus worms in dogs is therefore essential for efficiently controlling the disease. Detection kits based on three different technologies, i.e. sandwich ELISA, ELISA and gold immunodiffusion are currently marketed and used in China. The objective of this work was to assess the efficacy of these kits, in particular with respect to sensitivity and specificity. Four fecal antigen detection kits for canine echinococcosis covering the three technologies were obtained from companies and tested in parallel on 220 fecal samples. The results indicate that the performance is lower than expected, in particular in terms of sensitivity. The best results were obtained with the sandwich ELISA technology. The gold immunofiltration yielded the poorest results. In all cases, further development is needed to improve the performance of these kits, which represent a key element for the control of echinococcosis. Author summaryAlthough present worldwide, human echinococcosis is at its highest prevalence in Western China and particularly on the Tibetan plateau. Controlling echinococcosis is a national priority and routine monitoring must be established. Dogs are the main carriers of echinococcosis and surveying Echinococcus worms in dogs is therefore a key issue. Commercial detection kits are currently in use in China for monitoring the presence of Echinococcosis in dogs. These kits are based on three different technologies, i.e. sandwich ELISA with two monoclonal antibodies, ELISA, and gold immunodiffusion. National survey programs are essential for the control of echinococcosis and it is thus very important to assess the efficacy of these kits, planned to be used for the national survey programs. The work was thus undertaken to assess this efficacy, in particular with respect to sensitivity and specificity. Four fecal antigen detection kits for canine echinococcosis covering the three technologies were obtained from companies and tested in parallel on 220 fecal samples. The performance was lower than expected, in particular for their sensitivity, which ranged from 51.5% to 83.9% with only two samples displaying a worm burden lower than 100. Three out of four kits showed non-specific cross-reactions with other parasites. The best results were obtained with the sandwich ELISA technology, whereas gold immunofiltration yielded the poorest results. However, in all cases, further development is strongly needed to improve the performance of these kits, which represent a key element for the control of echinococcosis.