Allopatric divergence of cooperators confers cheating resistance and limits the effects of a defector mutation

Abstract

Social defectors may meet diverse cooperators. Genotype-by-genotype interactions may constrain the ranges of cooperators upon which particular defectors can cheat, limiting cheater spread. The bacterium Myxococcus xanthus undergoes cooperative multicellular development, but some developmental defectors cheat on cooperators during this process. In this study, interactions between a cheater disrupted at the signaling gene csgA and allopatrically diversified cooperators reveal a very small cheating range. Expectedly, the cheater failed to cheat on all natural-isolate cooperators owing to non-cheater-specific antagonisms. Surprisingly, lab-evolved cooperators that diverged from their cheating-susceptible ancestor by fewer than 20 mutations and without experiencing cheating had already exited the csgA mutants cheating range. Cooperators might also diversify in the potential for a mutation to reduce expression of cooperative trait or generate a cheating phenotype. A new csgA mutation constructed in several highly diverged cooperators generated diverse sporulation phenotypes, ranging from a complete defect to no defect, indicating that genetic backgrounds can limit the set of genomes in which a mutation creates a defector. Our results suggest that natural populations feature geographic mosaics of cooperators that have diversified in their susceptibility to particular cheaters and in the phenotypes generated by any given cooperation-gene mutation. Significance statementSelection on cooperators exploited by obligate cheaters can induce evolution of resistance to cheating. Here we show that cooperators can also rapidly evolve immunity to cheating simply as a byproduct of evolutionary divergence in environments in which cooperation and cheating at the focal trait do not occur because the trait is not expressed. We also find that differences in the genomic context in which a cooperation-gene mutation arises can profoundly alter its phenotypic effect and determine whether the mutation generates a social defect at all - a pre-requisite for obligate cheating. These findings suggest that general divergence of social populations under a broad range of environmental conditions can restrict both the set of mutations that might generate social defectors in the first place and the host range of such defectors once they arise.