1 Hz rTMS Is Not Inherently Inhibitory: Current Direction Determines Aftereffects and Reliability

Abstract

ObjectiveAftereffects of 1 Hz repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) often differ within and between subjects and thus show low reliability. In this study we investigated the mean and individual aftereffects of 1 Hz rTMS using two opposing current directions, their reliability and potential influences of current direction, participants sex and state on cortical excitability modulations. MethodsThirteen healthy, right-handed participants underwent four experimental sessions separated by at least 7 days receiving 2000 pulses of suprathreshold 1 Hz rTMS over the primary motor cortex per session. Two sessions were conducted with an induced current direction of anterior-posterior - posterior-anterior (AP-PA) and two sessions with a PA-AP current direction. Before and after rTMS, 100 single TMS pulses were administered with the respective current direction and electromyography was recorded from the first dorsal interosseous. Questionnaires on demographic data and subjective ratings were completed during the experiment. ResultsLinear mixed effect model analysis revealed that 1 Hz rTMS induced an excitatory aftereffect when applied with the PA-AP current direction, and no aftereffect with AP-PA. There was a substantial interindividual variability with only three subjects showing an inhibition to 1 Hz rTMS overall. Also, current direction was the only predictor of rTMS aftereffect. Reliability values of these aftereffects were in the poor to moderate range. ConclusionsCurrent direction plays a crucial role in determining 1 Hz rTMS aftereffects. Reliability was found to be moderate at best. Additional to current direction, more factors need to be considered to tailor the 1 Hz rTMS aftereffects individually.