Excessive chondrogenesis in the blastema initiates during hypomorphic limb regeneration in Xenopus froglet, but not during patterned limb regeneration in Xenopus tadpoles and newts

Xenopus laevis tadpoles and newts regenerate a limb almost completely after amputation, with recapitulation of the patten formation of the limb. Metamorphosed Xenopus froglets form a cone-shaped regenerating blastema, similar to tadpoles and newts, but ultimately regenerate only a hypomorphic cartilaginous spike. Previous study suggested that excessive chondrogenesis, distinct from Xenopus tadpoles, may occur in the regenerating limb of a froglet and may prevent pattern formation during regeneration. However, it remains unclear whether excessive chondrogenesis actually occurs in froglet blastemas. If it does, when does it initiate and how does it progress in the blastemas? To answer these questions, we examined the extent of chondrogenesis in regenerating blastemas which have the common morphological shapes observed in newts (Pleurodeles waltl), Xenopus laevis tadpoles, and froglets. To evaluate excessive chondrogenesis, we developed a simplified procedure using immunofluorescence for cartilage markers (Sox9 or Col2a1) and quantitative image analysis. Our analysis revealed that signs of excessive chondrogenesis were detected not in newts and tadpoles but in froglets blastemas. During limb regeneration in froglets, the first sign of excessive chondrogenesis was detected in the cone-shaped blastema at the medium bud (MB) stage, and excessive chondrogenesis progressed to a more severe state as the blastema grew. These results indicate that excessive chondrogenesis initiates specifically in froglet blastemas at the MB stage at the latest and progresses in a definite spatio-temporal manner. Further elucidation of the mechanisms underlying froglet-specific excessive chondrogenesis in the blastema may lead to the recovery of patterned limb regeneration in froglets with adequate inhibition of chondrogenesis.