bioRxivCell BiologyPreprint
Horizontal Transfer of Histone H3 by Mammalian Cells
P. L. Sulkowski, H. E. Nicholson, M. Z. Li, N. Perrimon, Z. Liu, W. G. Kaelin
Abstract
The authors have withdrawn their manuscript because many of the experiments described in this paper have not been reproducible, or at least are not robust, in the hands of other members of the Kaelin Laboratory who were not initially involved in this work. While we do see apparent secretion of histone H3 under some conditions, it is usually accompanied by secretion of histone H4. In this regard, the Halo tagged-histone H3 and Halo-tagged H4 constructs used for the single molecule imaging studies we reported, which seemingly confirmed specific secretion and transfer of histone H3, were purported to be sequence validated. Upon resequencing these constructs we discovered a non-synonymous mutation in the Halo tag of the H4 construct. We then redid the imaging experiments with the corrected Halo-H4 together with Halo-H3 and, in contrast to our earlier study, unfused Halo. These experiments were difficult to interpret because of the background signal seen with the unfused Halo but did not support specific secretion and transfer of histones (let alone specific secretion and transfer of histone H3). We have, in some experiments, observed transfer of H3-Cre into reporter cells ex vivo and in vivo, but 1) the transfer is not specific for H3-Cre versus H4-Cre, 2) the transfer efficiency is highly variable, and 3) the transfer efficiency is typically much less than reported in our original paper. We do not yet know whether this lack of reproducibility and robustness reflects technical and biological variables that we do not yet understand and hence were not captured in our experimental protocols. Therefore, the authors do not wish this work to be cited as reference for the project. If you have any questions, please contact the corresponding author.
- organism: mouse
- assay: proteomics
- research focus: cell signaling & trafficking
- approach: experimental assay
Reproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- N-terminal modification of Histone H3 inhibits H3K27M-mediated loss of H3K27 trimethylation
Nicolas Poux, Daren F Zhang, … Pratiti Bandopadhayay·bioRxiv·Jan 24, 2025
- Observation of histone nuclear import in living cells: implications in the processing of newly synthesised H3.1 & H4
Michael James Apta‐Smith, Juan Ramon Hernandez-Fernaud, Andrew James Bowman·The EMBO JournalPeer-reviewed·Sep 3, 2018
- A Vector System Encoding Histone H3 Mutants Facilitates Manipulations of the Neuronal Epigenome
Sophie Warren, Sen Xiong, … José‐Manuel Baizabal·Scientific ReportsPeer-reviewed·Oct 18, 2024
- Exogenous expression of a histone H3.3 isoform causes extranuclear divisions in the C. elegans intestine
Carmen Herrera Sandoval, Christopher Borchers, … Scott Takeo Aoki·bioRxiv·Apr 10, 2025
- Molecular mechanism of parental H3/H4 recycling at a replication fork
F. Nagae, Y. Murayama, T. Terakawa·bioRxiv·Mar 7, 2024
- A specific role for Importin-5 and NASP in theimport and nuclear hand-off of monomeric H3
A. J. Pardal, A. J. Bowman·bioRxiv·Oct 19, 2021