Effects of Host-Tree Foliage on Polymorphism in an Insect Pathogen

Abstract

The theory of host-pathogen interactions has successfully shown that persistent pathogen virulence may be explained through tradeoffs between different pathogen fitness components, but classical theory cannot explain pathogen coexistence. More recent theory invokes both tradeoffs and environmental heterogeneity, but resembles classical theory in focusing on a limited range of possible tradeoffs, and therefore has seen few applications. To better understand the usefulness of tradeoff theory for explaining pathogen coexistence in nature, we measured components of pathogen fitness in two distantly related morphotypes of a baculovirus that infects larvae of the Douglas-fir tussock moth (Orgyia pseudotsugata). We show that the two morphotypes vary in multiple components of fitness, including the probability of infection given exposure to the pathogen, the incubation time of the pathogen, variability in the incubation time of the pathogen, and the detectability of the pathogen. Moreover, because the baculovirus is transmitted when host larvae accidentally consume infectious virus particles while feeding on foliage of the insects host trees, the strength and direction of the differences in fitness components of the two morphotypes depends on the host-tree species on which host larvae consume the virus. Through simulations of a model parameterized using our experimental data, we demonstrate how several varying fitness components can work in concert to promote strain coexistence, particularly highlighting the role of variability in incubation time. Our results suggest that the two morphotypes may coexist because of variation in forest tree-species composition, providing important empirical evidence that tradeoffs and environmental heterogeneity can together modulate pathogen competition.