Biomechanics and Modeling in MechanobiologyBioengineeringPeer-reviewed journal article
Constitutive neural networks for main pulmonary arteries: Discovering the undiscovered
Thibault VervenneiD, Mathias PeirlinckiD, Nele FamaeyiD, Ellen Kuhl AiD
Abstract
Accurate modeling of cardiovascular tissues is crucial for understanding and predicting their behavior in various physiological and pathological conditions. In this study, we specifically focus on the pulmonary artery in the context of the Ross procedure, using neural networks to discover the most suitable material model. The Ross procedure is a complex cardiac surgery where the patients own pulmonary valve is used to replace the diseased aortic valve. Ensuring the successful long-term outcomes of this intervention requires a detailed understanding of the mechanical properties of pulmonary tissue. Constitutive artificial neural networks offer a novel approach to capture such complex stressstrain relationships. Here we design and train different constitutive neural networks to characterize the hyperelastic, anisotropic behavior of the main pulmonary artery. Informed by experimental biaxial testing data under various axial-circumferential loading ratios, these networks automatically discover the inherent material behavior, without the limitations of predefined mathematical models. We regularize the model discovery using cross-sample feature selection and explore its sensitivity to the collagen fiber distribution. Strikingly, we uniformly discover an isotropic exponential first-invariant term and an anisotropic quadratic fifth-invariant term. We show that constitutive models with both these terms can reliably predict arterial responses under diverse loading conditions. Our results provide crucial improvements in experimental data agreement, and enhance our understanding into the biomechanical properties of pulmonary tissue. The model outcomes can be used in a variety of computational frameworks of autograft adaptation, ultimately improving the surgical outcomes after the Ross procedure.
- organism: human
- assay: metabolomics
- research focus: cell type annotation
- approach: deep learning
- approach: experimental assay
In-depth summary
Claude Opus 5.5 · xhigh effort · 8 Nov 2026 · from the full text of version 2 (22 Jan 2025) · CC BY 4.0
Constitutive artificial neural networks trained on biaxial tests of 8 ovine main pulmonary artery samples consistently discover a two-term model: exponential first-invariant plus quadratic fifth-invariant terms.
The Ross procedure's main failure mode is dilatation of the pulmonary autograft under four- to fivefold higher aortic pressures, and simulations of how the autograft remodels depend on a pulmonary constitutive law that experts usually choose in advance. This work runs automated invariant-based model discovery on new ovine biaxial data, finds a sparse, interpretable law, and benchmarks it against the classical Holzapfel-Gasser-Ogden (HGO) model.
Key results
ShownWhen one network is trained jointly on all 8 samples with the fiber angle fixed at 70°, it consistently selects one isotropic and one anisotropic invariant term. The same two features, exp([I1-3]) and [I5-1]^2, recur across the unregularized and L1-regularized runs.
The cross-sample loss covered n = 8 samples, with αreg = 0 and αreg = 0.001. The network can express 2^16 term combinations (more than 60,000 models). The unregularized result matches the behavior previously discovered for layers of healthy human aortas. Each regularization condition took about 20 minutes to train. · 2.3 Constitutive artificial neural network; 3.2 Cross-sample feature selection; Figure legends
ShownThe reduced two-term law (exponential I1 plus quadratic I5) fits better than the HGO model and is much less sensitive to the assumed collagen fiber angle.
Averaged over n = 8 samples with fixed angles from 0° to 90°, the reduced model kept R^2 > 0.9 across the whole range, while HGO fit well only for 45° ≤ α ≤ 50°. On the representative sample, the reduced model gave R^2 > 0.99 (α = 50.9°). HGO gave c1 = 1.95 kPa, k1 = 0.77 kPa, k2 = 0.145 (α = 49.0°) with a lower R^2. · 3.4 Traditional model fitting; 3.5 Reduced model discovery; Figure legends
ShownA per-sample sweep over fixed fiber angles shows that anisotropic terms appear mainly when fibers are oriented circumferentially. The HGO model's exponential quadratic I4 term is almost never selected.
The sweep used 11 angles from 0° to 90° for each of the n = 8 samples. Without L1, exp([I1-3]) dominates and anisotropic terms appear mostly for α > 45°. With L1 (αreg = 0.01), [I5-1]^2 is most common and I1 terms give way to I2 terms. exp([I4-1]^2) occurs in 1% of fits without L1 and 0% with L1. · 3.3 Fiber angle analysis; 3.5 Reduced model discovery; Figure legends
ShownOn one representative sample, unregularized discovery with a fitted angle gives a three-term model and a nearly isotropic fiber angle. L1 at αreg = 0.01 prunes this to a single I5 term and the fit gets much worse, which the authors read as over-regularization.
Unregularized, fitted α: exp([I1-3]), exp([I5-1]) and [I5-1]^2, with R^2 > 0.99 and α = 49.8°. L1, fitted α: only [I5-1]^2, with R^2 < 0.84 and α = 49.0°. Fixed α = 70° without L1: R^2 > 0.98, with the full set of I1 terms active. Each run took about 4 minutes on a standard laptop. · 3.1 Sample-specific model discovery; Figure legends
SuggestedFitting the reduced law jointly to all samples converges to an almost purely circumferential fiber direction. The authors say this agrees with published collagen orientation distributions for ovine pulmonary arteries.
The all-sample reduced fit gave α = 89.9°, with weights w1,2 = 0.424, w2,2 = 8.48 kPa, w1,15 = 0.222 and w2,15 = 0.112 kPa. The microstructural agreement rests on a cited prior study and was not measured in this work. · 3.5 Reduced model discovery; Figure legends
Methods, data and reproducibility
A transversely isotropic, incompressible constitutive artificial neural network (CANN) takes the invariants I1, I2, I4 and I5, raises each to linear and squared powers, and applies identity and exponential activations, giving 16 strain energy terms. Analytic biaxial stresses are fitted by weighted least squares with optional L1 lasso, per sample or across samples, with the fiber angle either fixed or fitted.
- Unpublished planar biaxial tensile data on 10 mm x 10 mm main pulmonary artery squares (2 per root): stretches tracked by digital image correlation (DIC), axial:circumferential ratios 2:1, 1:1 and 1:2 · sheep (ovine) · n = n = 8 samples (4 pulmonary roots x 2)
- Methods & tools
- Constitutive artificial neural network (CANN), Holzapfel-Gasser-Ogden (HGO) model, Adam optimizer, L1 (lasso) regularization, Glorot normal initializer, VIC 2D digital image correlation (Correlated Solutions), MessPhysik Zwick/Roell planar biaxial tester, Micro Laser Scanner (Acacia Technology)
- Experimental conditions
- About 4 minutes per single-sample run on a standard laptop; about 20 minutes per regularization condition for the all-sample network; about 90 seconds for the reduced two-term network.
- Reproducibility gaps
- No code repository, framework or software versions are given. The biaxial dataset is unpublished and is said to be available only in the Supplementary Materials, which are not part of the provided text.
Limitations (6)
- Biaxial responses varied a lot between samples, even from the same animal. Cross-sample feature selection averages over this variation, and the authors suggest Bayesian CANNs to model the data uncertainty. · stated by the authors
- Collagen is modeled as two symmetric fiber families with identical properties and no dispersion. The dominant fiber angle remains uncertain, and because both HGO and the new law have three parameters plus an angle, a unique fit is unlikely. · stated by the authors
- The discovered law has not been validated in a different mechanical setup (for example extension-inflation or pressure-diameter tests), nor shown to predict stresses for untrained data. The authors list this as future work. · stated by the authors
- The network can only use predefined linear, quadratic and exponential invariant terms. The authors note this limits what it can learn, in exchange for weights with a clear physical meaning. · stated by the authors
- The claims of predictive generalization rest on in-sample R^2. No loading ratio, sample or animal was held out, and the data come from only four sheep, so out-of-sample accuracy of the two-term law is untested. · noted in this summary
- The L1 strengths (0.01 and 0.001) were chosen without any reported tuning, and 0.01 pruned the fitted-angle fit of one sample down to a single term. The sweep legends report 96 training routines for 11 angles by 8 samples, which does not multiply out, so the run totals are unclear. · noted in this summary
Read this if you model the mechanics of arterial or valve tissue, simulate Ross procedure autograft remodeling, or want a worked example of sparse, invariant-based constitutive model discovery from biaxial data.
- Citations
- 16
- FWCI
- 3.66
- Field percentile
- top 6%
Reproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- Fiber dispersion in the right ventricle: A comparison of constitutive neural network predictions with experimental data
Parag Ingalkar, Sotirios Kakaletsis, … Denisa Martonová·Journal of BiomechanicsPeer-reviewed·Aug 21, 2026
- Automated model discovery for human brain using Constitutive Artificial Neural Networks
K. Linka, S. R. St. Pierre, E. Kuhl·Acta BiomaterialiaPeer-reviewed·Apr 1, 2023
- Automated model discovery for human cardiac tissue: Discovering the best model and parameters
Denisa Martonová, Mathias Peirlinck, … Ellen Kuhl A·Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and EngineeringPeer-reviewed·May 29, 2024
- Automated model discovery for skin:Discovering the best model, data, and experiment
K. Linka, A. Buganza Tepole, … E. Kuhl·bioRxiv·Dec 19, 2022
- Principal-stretch-based constitutive neural networks autonomously discover a subclass of Ogden models for human brain tissue
S. R. St. Pierre, K. Linka, E. Kuhl·bioRxiv·Jan 14, 2023
- Automated model discovery for muscle using constitutive recurrent neural networks
L. M. Wang, K. Linka, E. Kuhl·bioRxiv·May 9, 2023