Evolution of transmissible spongiform encephalopathy and the prion protein gene (PRNP) in mammals

Abstract

Wildlife managers are concerned with transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSEs) as they are currently incurable, always fatal, and have the potential to cross species boundaries. Although a wide range of mammals exhibit TSEs, it is currently unclear whether they are evolutionarily clustered or if TSE+ species are randomly distributed phylogenetically. We tested whether mammalian species with TSEs are phylogenetically underdispersed on a tree derived from 102 PRNP sequences obtained from the Orthologous Mammalian Markers database. We determined that the PRNP tree was topologically congruent with a species tree for these same 102 taxa constructed from 20 aligned gene sequences, excluding the PRNP sequence. Searches in Google Scholar were done to determine whether a species is known to have expressed a TSE. TSEs were present in a variety of orders excluding Chiroptera, Eulipotyphyla, and Lagomorpha and no marine mammals (Artiodactyla) were recorded to have a TSE. We calculated the phylogenetic signal of binary traits (D-Value) to infer if the phylogenetic distribution of TSEs are conserved or dispersed. The occurrence of TSEs in both trees is non-random (Species tree D-value = 0.291; PRNP tree D-value = 0.273), and appears to have arisen independently in the recent history of different mammalian groups. Our findings suggest that the evolution of TSEs develops in groups of species irrespective of PRNP genotype. The evolution of TSEs merits continued exploration at a more in-depth phylogenetic level, as well as the search for genetic combinations that might underlie TSE diseases.